Defense News ,India :- In the deep sea, there's a quiet competition between two types of attack submarines: the Hangor class from Pakistan and the Kalvari class from India. These submarines are advanced, but they have differences that make them unique.
Size and Weight:
Hangor: Bigger, weighing around 2,800 tons. It's spacious inside, which can make it more comfortable for the crew.
Kalvari: Smaller, at 1,775 tons. It's more nimble in shallow waters but might not have as much space inside.
Propulsion:
Hangor: Uses Chinese diesel-electric engines and an Air-Independent Propulsion (AIP) system, which lets it stay underwater longer. We don't know much about the AIP system.
Kalvari: Relies on regular diesel-electric engines, so it can't stay underwater as long as the Hangor. But it's working on adding an indigenous Fuel Cell AIP to improve this.
Armament:
Hangor: Has six 533mm torpedo tubes and can launch missiles like Babur 3 and anti-ship missiles. We don't know much about its exact capabilities.
Kalvari: Equipped with six 533mm torpedo tubes and can launch a wider range of weapons, including heavyweight torpedoes, anti-ship missiles like Exocet, and even DRDO developed Land-attack cruise missiles like ITCM and BrahMos-NG. Its payload capacity is well-defined.
Sensor Suite:
Hangor: We don't have a lot of details, but it likely has modern sonar and electronic warfare systems.
Kalvari: Equipped with advanced French technology called S-Cube, including top-notch sonar and electronic warfare systems. S-Cube is also equipped on the Four Brazilian Navy’s Scorpène and also on the Peruvian Navy’s Type 209/1200 submarines.
Key Differences:
Endurance: Hangor might have an edge because of its AIP system, but we don't know much about it.
Weaponry: Kalvari has a wider variety of weapons, giving it more flexibility.
Sensor Suite: Both are probably modern, but Kalvari's French technology is proven to work well.
Choosing a Winner:
It's hard to pick a clear winner because we don't have enough information about the Hangor class. While Hangor might have some advantages, Kalvari's proven abilities and diverse weaponry make it a strong contender. Ultimately, it depends on how each submarine is used and how well its crew is trained.
Looking Beyond:
These submarines are just part of a bigger picture. Factors like training, support systems, and overall naval strategy are also important. Understanding all these factors helps us see the true potential of these submarines.
——— End of Article ———
